I have a tendency to like an idea until I hit a block where the story doesn't hit one of my criteria.
For me, the main storyline has to be:
#1 - Something I know about
#2 - Something very different
#3 - Something with meaning
#4 - I need to already know how it begins and how it ends, and the ending has to be awesome.
#5 - There has to be at least one character that is super different
#6 - There has to be a major twist even I wouldn't see coming
So far I'm 5 out of 6. We will see where it goes!
Wish me luck:)